Homebuyer’s Remorse: why does it arise and how can we deal with it?
According to Charlotte Bronte, ‘remorse is the poison of life,’ and it certainly isn’t uncommon to experience regret when it comes to making momentous decisions: career opportunities (missed or taken), starting or ending relationships, and major purchases. Property will be one of the most expensive purchases made in a lifetime, so it’s no surprise buyers want to make the right choice. Yet research from price comparison site Go Compare (2021) showed that over 19000 new homeowners regretted buying their home. Similarly, a 2020 study by Hilary’s Blinds suggested that 44% of British homeowners wouldn’t by their new house again if given the chance. Anecdotal evidence seems to support this; you often don’t have to look far to find a friend or colleague who’s put their property back on the market less than 12-24 months after moving in. Given the sums of money involved in buying property, alongside the time and emotional effort required, buyers are heavily invested in this decision. Having regrets post-purchase can feel like you’ve won the battle but lost the war: you’ve got the house, but was it the right one?
The following article will take a look at the psychology behind Buyer’s Remorse and how it applies to property purchases: when does it arise, and why? What factors help us avoid Buyer’s Remorse when it comes to a property purchase? And how can we deal with it if we’re suffering?
Cognitive Dissonance: the source of Buyer’s Remorse
Since the 1950s, psychologists have attributed Buyer’s Remorse to the phenomenon of Cognitive Dissonance: a psychological unease created when an individual holds conflicting beliefs, ideas, values or behaviours (Festinger, 1957). This comes into play with property purchases, as with any other purchase, when the outcome doesn’t meet the buyer’s expectations in one or more ways.
There are said to be three conditions under which Buyer’s Remorse can arise (Festinger, 1957), and these factors all come into play in property purchases:
Effort
A great many resources are invested in a property purchase: money, time, and the sheer graft of searching available properties, arranging viewings (often multiple times for the same property), making offers, negotiating offers etc. The more effort expended in the purchase, the greater the reward needs to be to avoid Cognitive Dissonance.
Responsibility
Who is responsible for the decision? Ultimately, the buyers and sellers. Buyers have the agency to choose the property they want from the options available and put forward the price they are willing to pay. Arguably, there is nobody else to blame for a poor decision when it comes to property purchases; therefore, the level of responsibility (on the part of the buyer) is high.
Commitment
As most homeowners want to live in their property for a considerable length of time after purchasing (a lifetime in the case of ‘forever homes’) the scale of the commitment adds weight to the purchase. Furthermore, property purchases there is no easy way to reverse the decision, heightening the commitment further. Of course, you can always put the property back on the market, but this involves more money, time and effort. In the case of some undisclosed but vital issue with the property, legal action could be taken against the seller on the basis that they misrepresented the property. However, legal action is usually only appropriate if some major aspect of the property wasn’t disclosed, for example disputes with neighbours, invasive species or structural issues, and Buyer’s Remorse is commonly triggered without buyers being legally ‘mis-sold’.
Buyer’s Remorse arises when low reward (i.e. not being happy with the property purchased) is aligned with high levels of responsibility, effort and commitment involved in the purchase. However, Schwartz (2004) adds that encountering near-misses, for example having an offer on an equivalent or better property rejected, also adds to feelings of remorse.
Furthermore, Schwartz (2004) says we are more likely to regret a decision to purchase if we can easily imagine alternatives; in the case of property purchases, it’s never been easier to view a whole host of alternative properties that fit the criteria we’re looking for, in great detail (virtual tours, drone photography etc.), and information this wealth of information is readily available online.
Converse to the maxim ‘time heals all’, Schwartz (2004) also notes that Buyer’s Remorse tends to prevail. Moreover, as time goes on there is a proclivity to regret decisions to purchase more than a failure to make a decision in the first place; this is known as the ‘Omission Bias’. Applying this to property purchases, it could be argued that we tend to experience greater remorse following a purchase compared to an instance where we ‘missed out’ on a particular property by failing to offer in time.
Do I have Buyer’s Remorse? Or just the benefit of hindsight?
There is a difference between nagging doubts and certain regret. On getting the keys to your new home, it is quite common to suddenly feel the weight of homeownership. Whether this is your first home or your fifth, every property is different and will require a new level of care and attention that only becomes apparent once you are responsible for it.
For example, there may be more things in need of repair or replacement than you thought. Maybe you decided to upsize and don’t like the realisation of having more to clean day in, day out. You might have borrowed at the upper end of your budget, and the reality of living on a shoestring in a property that requires significant investment itself is frightening. Or maybe you’ve downsized, and the reality of cramming your treasured belongings into less space feels claustrophobic. In many cases, these doubts or uncertainties will pass. In other cases, the wisdom of the purchase might be called into question.
Other concerns may be tied to permanent features of the property, like location: the immediate area or surroundings might not live up to your pre-purchase expectations. For example, what you thought was a quiet cul-de-sac might host noisy parties and gatherings every other weekend. Perhaps the move was part of a larger relocation for work or a relationship, and you were perhaps not aware of some aspects of the area that locals are privy to (despite thorough research). In some cases, these can feel can like ‘deal-breakers’ post-purchase and again call into question the wisdom of the decision.
Psychologists Sweeney, Hausknecht & Soutar (2000) devised a scale to measure Buyer’s Remorse. They posited three ‘dimensions’ to the phenomenon: emotional, questioning the wisdom of purchase and having concerns over the deal. Emotionally, individuals might feel sick, angry with themselves, hollow, or scared. They may question whether they really needed to buy the property at all? Was it the right house for them? Might there have been a better house if they had waited? Lastly, there may be considerable concern over the specifics of the purchase price: have I been swindled? Did the sellers lie about the lovely neighbours, the expected maintenance costs, the condition of the property (specific areas or in general)? Is there something wrong with the property?! Was my decision swayed (by sellers, family/friends etc.) when I didn’t even realise it? Research suggests these questions and concerns are symptomatic of Buyer’s Remorse.
How can we deal with Buyer’s Remorse?
We know that Buyer’s Remorse stems from a conflict between our beliefs, values and behaviours: this makes us psychologically uncomfortable. However, our psyche works hard to minimise this discomfort by distorting our memory of the decision to buy. This is known as our ‘Choice-Supportive Bias’.
Choice-Supportive Bias is a tendency to think more positively about our decision, focusing on the advantages that the purchase confers and downplaying the negatives. We reframe the ‘narrative’ around our decision to purchase, reframing this in a positive light. This bias is stronger the more involvement that was required in the decision. So, in the case of property purchases (requiring high levels of involvement), we will be strongly biased towards those positive aspects of our purchase in hindsight. Furthermore, we actively seek out information that aligns with our choice and assuages any doubts we may have.
However, Litt & Thomas (2010) noted that this defence is built on shaky foundations. Choice-Supportive Bias is not impervious to attack: when we are presented with evidence of the negatives, the defence falls apart. So, whilst we might convince ourselves that we got a good deal for a smaller-than-ideal property within walking distance of an outstanding school, when a larger property down the road sells for the same price, the illusion is shattered. We didn’t get a good deal, and we know it.
Another way we distort our view of the decision to buy a property we then regret is by passing responsibility onto others. Claiming that the influence of family, friends or a partner pushed the purchase ahead without our full acceptance helps minimise our own responsibility in the decision (Festinger, 1957; Schwartz, 2004).
If these cognitive defences don’t assuage our Buyer’s Remorse, in practical terms what can be done to help? Firstly, discuss your feelings and concerns with any joint owners; you may find your concerns are shared, or they already have some ideas to improve the troublesome aspects of property. It might help to also discuss with someone completely uninvolved in the purchase: an independent, objective viewpoint can put your concerns in perspective and help filter out the emotions involved.
Along with any co-owners, list out the reasons you chose the property: what are the positives, and why are they important? Then, counter this with a list of negatives and break this down into what you can do to ameliorate them. Think about the changes you can make to the property, both short- and long-term. Short-term, how can you arrange furniture to hide flooring or décor that is in poor condition? How can you let in more light? Which rooms or areas are the ‘worst’? Which will see heavy usage? Which need to be prioritised? Focusing on improving one room or area at a time helps to break down the project into achievable steps and reduce overwhelm. Not only that, but making at least one room your own, with a good standard of décor and handiwork, will give you a space to retreat to when the rest may feel unbearable. If space is an issue, research what changes will add living space and value to the property, even if these aren’t achievable immediately: garage or loft conversions, extensions or structural alterations can vastly change the space available and improve the ‘feel’ of the house in line with your requirements.
Feelings of Buyer’s Remorse might be exacerbated by the frustrations of finding your way in a new home, which can make it feel even more alien and at-odds with yourself. If it is an option, research suggests that post-purchase communication with the seller can help (Schwartz, 2004). Understanding the intricacies of how the previous owners lived in and used the property might ease your adaptation to it. Exchanging information on some esoteric aspects of the property, like changing bulbs in an obscure light-fitting, the exact location of a well-hidden water-meter, tips on maintaining fixtures like wood flooring or controlling complex heating systems can all help make the house feel like home far quicker than learning the hard way. Find out if the sellers experienced the same feelings or concerns you have? How did they deal with it? It also helps to know that the property was a loved home for another person or family, so it can be your home in time too (although it might not feel like it at first).
Festinger (1957) notes that one way to deal with Buyer’s Remorse is to ‘reverse’ the decision. Although it is a costly option when it comes to property purchases, we can always sell up and move on (literally and figuratively). In this way, we can accept the mistakes that were made in the decision to purchase, take the hit and learn from the experience going forward as a wiser homebuyer.
Tavris and Aronson (2016) claim that self-compassion is key when it comes to dealing with Buyer’s Remorse. Understanding why we feel as we do can help us ultimately accept the possibility of error and learn from this going forward. So, in practical terms this could mean thinking kindlier about your role in the property purchase decision. You made the best decision with the information you had at the time; this is the situation you are in now, and you can take practical steps to address the most concerning aspects of the property (or sell up and buy another, with the benefit of this experience under your belt).
As with most things, prevention is better than cure, and the best way to deal with Buyer’s Remorse is to avoid it entirely. For this, thorough research into your property purchase is key. Key elements of research can include the following, although more detailed articles on this are available:
- Having a clear set of criteria for your property
- Non-negotiables and negotiables: what/where are you willing to compromise, and what are your deal-breakers? Be firm with these and your rationale behind them and think very carefully about changing priorities down the line.
- Multiple viewings: make use of every opportunity you have to see the property before (and after) offering. Better still, meet the sellers. Forewarned is forearmed, and the more you know about the property the better informed your decision will be.
- Get the appropriate levels of surveys for the property; again, forewarned is forearmed, and you are far less likely to be blindsided by some major fault or concern with the property after purchase if you have instructed the appropriate survey or surveys during conveyancing. Mortgage lenders often stipulate a particular level of survey, and your conveyancing solicitor may also recommend specific reports based on the results of searches or queries.
- Familiarise yourself with the area. If you’re not entirely familiar with the area you’re purchasing in, make a point of experiencing it at different times of day and across weekdays and weekends. This can help ensure you aren’t surprised by the level of vehicle or pedestrian traffic at peak times and associated noise and congestion, parking problems, antisocial behaviour in the area etc. If your move will mean a new daily commute or walks to school, try out the route you will take (again, at different times) to ensure you’re comfortable with this and pinpoint any concerns.
- Careful consideration of offers. Buyer’s Remorse often stems from the feeling that we’ve overpaid for something, as the quality or reality didn’t meet our high expectations. Carefully considering your offer will help ensure you don’t feel out of pocket after getting the keys.
Summary
Property is likely the biggest purchase we’ll ever make, so it’s understandable that homebuyers want to get it right. It can be heartbreaking to get the keys to a new home only to feel that the time, money and effort invested in the purchase hasn’t given you the high reward you’d expected. Moreover, ‘reversing’ the decision- that is, selling up and moving on – requires another considerable investment of time, money and effort. Research suggests that Buyer’s Remorse is more common among recent homeowners than we might assume. Psychological theory tells us we regret purchases where we hold conflicting beliefs, values or ideas, or behave contrary to these: in short, when a property purchase doesn’t meet expectations, we feel distinctly uneasy about it.
In a dynamic housing market, buyers never know what property will be available around the corner. Yet with thorough research, a clear set of criteria and the appropriate property professionals involved, buyers can make the best decision they can with the information they have. For those suffering Buyer’s Remorse, our psyche does try to minimise the unease by skewing our beliefs towards the positives. Where this fails, trying to look at your purchase objectively and focusing on practical solutions can help. Specifically, what bothers you about the property? What can you do to change this in the long- and short-term? Breaking this down into small, achievable steps, room by room, will help make the transformation feel achievable.
References
Sweeney, J.C., Hausknecht, D. and Soutar, G. (2000). Cognitive Dissonance after purchase: A multidimensional scale. Psychology and Marketing, 17(5), pp. 369-385.
Festinger, L. (1957). A theory of cognitive dissonance. Stanford University Press.
Schwartz, B. (2004). The Paradox of Choice: Why more is less. HarperCollins e-books.
Tavris, C, and Aronson, E. (2016). Mistakes Were Made (But Not by Me). Great Britain, Pinter & Martin Ltd.