Estate agent or auction?
A quick sale at auction is tempting but at what price?
Selling a house can be slow, uncertain and stressful. That’s why the promise of a speedy, guaranteed sale at auction is so appealing. Frustrated sellers are increasingly turning away from traditional estate agents in search of a quicker, more straightforward process.
Stuart Collar-Brown, president of NAVA Propertymark, the auctioneering arm of Propertymark, has seen the shift first hand. “We’ve seen the percentage of properties sold at auction double in the last four years.” Much of this growth is due to the rise of online property auctions which boomed during the pandemic and have remained popular due to their convenience.
Some sellers see auctions to avoid delays, collapsing chains or last-minute gazumping. But while auctions offer benefits, they’re not right for everyone. So, when does it make sense to sell your property at auction and when should you stick with an estate agent?
When to sell at auction
The main advantage of an auction is speed. Selling at auction will typically take nine weeks from start to finish, according to property auction websites Probate Auction and Resi Auction. That’s significantly faster than the 26-week average of an estate agent sale.
“The prolonged process of selling through estate agents is impacted by chain buyers, mortgage lenders and/or complete change of mind from the buyer, sometimes at a late stage,” notes Probate Auction. But bear in mind preparation for an auction takes time. You’ll need to prepare legal documents and marketing material in advance.
Then there’s certainty. “As soon as the hammer goes down, that’s it – the sale is legally binding,” explains Richard Baddams, director of Hamwic independent estate agents in Southampton. There’s no risk of the buyer pulling out later, which can be a huge relief for buyers.
Auctions also offer transparency. The bidding process is open, so everyone can see what’s happening, whether in person or online. For sellers of probate properties that’s a big advantage over behind-closed-doors negotiations of traditional sales.
What type of properties sell best at auction?
One quirky example is No Man’s Fort, a 19th century sea fort in the Solent. Originally marketed for £4.2 million in 2020, it eventually sold at auction for just £1.12 million in 2024.
“Auctions are mainly for properties that are unusual or rundown, in need of renovation or simply struggling to sell on the open market. Sellers can set a reserve price – the minimum they will accept – in the hope that a bidding war will push up the price,” says Baddams
However, online auctions don’t always spark the same adrenaline-fuelled bidding wars you might see in a room full of eager buyers. “You must be able to tolerate the reserve price as a bottom line, as there is a risk that your property will only sell at the reserve price on auction day,” warns Auction Link.
While not ideal for every seller, auctions work particularly well for probate sales, homes requiring significant renovation and those with legal complications.
Why the rise in auction sales now?
The current surge isn’t just down to frustrated homeowners. Landlords and second-home owners are looking to offload properties ahead of the anticipated increase in capital gains tax – currently 18 per cent for basic rate taxpayers and 24 per cent for higher rate taxpayers on property sales.
New government reforms boosting tenant rights and increasing the tax burden on landlords are also fuelling the trend. In many cases, auctions provide a faster, less stressful exit strategy.
Private sellers, meanwhile, are often motivated by frustration with the traditional process. Delays, broken chains and costly estate agent fees are all reasons why people are exploring the auction route. “Auctions can be a good option for people who want a quick move and who value speed over top price,” says Baddams.
It’s worth noting that while auctions can help you avoid estate agent fees, they’re not free. Most auctioneers charge a commission, typically around two per cent plus VAT, if the property sells. Some auctioneers also charge fixed fees, so check the small print. “The cost of selling at auction usually works out about the same as using a good high street estate agent,” explains Auction Link.
When to use an estate agent
So, when should you use an estate agent? A good local estate agent can help manage complex chains and reduce the stress of selling. They offer valuable local market knowledge, access to a ready pool of interested buyers and can guide you through pricing, marketing and negotiations.
While auctions carry the risk of selling at the reserve price, a skilled agent aims to maximise your sale price by setting a realistic figure from the outset, based on comparable local properties and generating interest through target marketing.
They will also conduct viewings, handle negotiations with buyers and create professional marketing materials.
“Independent estate agents are often more knowledgeable, more personable and less target driven,” says Baddams. “They also tend to have a lower staff turnover, which can mean a better service.”
Be wary of agents who overvalue your property just to win your business. Overpricing can backfire, leading to price drops and cause your listing to sit on property portals, which ultimately puts off buyers.
When choosing an agent, ask for recommendations from friends, family and neighbours. Review their recent sales, assess their marketing materials, including photos and compare commission rates and services.
Auctions offer speed, transparency and a legally binding sale. But they’re not always the best option. If your home is in good condition and likely to attract strong buyer interest, a skilled estate agent might help you achieve a better price. On the other hand, if you’re looking for a fast sale, the property needs work or you’ve had trouble selling, going under the hammer might be your best move.