Buying in a National Landscape
What is an AONB/National Landscape?
According to the National Landscape Association (NLA), AONB/National Landscapes are “places with national importance, protected for the nation's benefit”. The November 2023 re-brand aimed to highlight the national significance of the areas, akin to our National Parks. An AONB is a legal, statutory designation of land marked on a map. An interactive Defra map provides details on where these areas fall (under ‘Designations’, ‘Landscape’, and ‘Statutory’ filters).
There are 46 AONB in England, Wales and Northern Ireland; Scotland has 40 National Scenic Areas (as of September 2024). AONBs cover 14-15% of land in England. The environmental and scenic importance of these areas is quite apparent: NLA state that AONBs store at least 17.5% of England’s carbon in soil, account for 20% of England’s woodland and 30% of England’s Ancient Woodland.
The legal responsibility for AONB lies with the respective Local Authorities. The Countryside and Rights of Way Act (2000) states that all Local Authorities with land in AONB must have a plan for managing the area, including planning policies. National Landscape Teams work in tandem with a number of partners to manage the AONB. These partners include private landowners, government agencies (e.g. the Environment Agency), national conservation organisations (e.g. Natural England, Natural Resources Wales, NatureScot), and district and parish councils, amongst others. Together, they coordinate management and conservation works, and they can also advise on planning proposals.
Benefits to Living in an AONB
An Area of Natural Beauty does what it says on the tin: as such, the most apparent benefit to a property in an AONB will be that it is in an exceptionally scenic environment. Considering buying in an AONB is therefore highly aligned with countryside living and access to the countryside, something that more and more people strive for in the wake of the Covid 19 pandemic and the changes lifestyle and working patterns that, for many, came with it. With 170 million people visiting AONBs per year (according to the NLA), the appeal of these areas is undoubtable.
Furthermore, AONBs are protected under the Countryside and Rights of Way Act (2000) such that development is highly controlled. Each AONB has a Management Plan, reviewed every five years, covering the unique characteristics of the area, as well as the aims, objectives and principles of management and, crucially for homeowners, Local Authority Planning Policies. These Management Plans are guided by the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF), and Local Authorities have to adopt this in their own planning decisions. The planning restrictions placed on properties within an AONB by no means prevent development, extensions and conversions etc., but it is significantly more difficult to gain planning permission. In broad terms, planning policies within AONBs usually seek to ensure that development: enhances or conserves the natural beauty of the environment; is in line with the qualities and characteristics of the landscape; is appropriate and beneficial for the local community. As a result, homeowners in these areas can enjoy a certain level of protection from change in their surroundings.
In line with these benefits, AONBs are command a higher price than in other parts of the country. Nationwide Building Society (2020) claimed property value was on average 13% higher within AONBs, compared to like-for-like properties elsewhere. The four AONBs with the highest average property values were: the Surrey Hills (£750K), the Chilterns (£613K), the High Weald (£490K) and the Cotswolds (£463K) (Nationwide Building Society, 2020). Knight Frank (2021) suggests the average property premium in AONBs is more akin to 32.7%, compared to equivalent properties within 5km of the AONB boundary. Breaking this down further, Knight Frank cite the percentage premium in the Surrey Hills as 32.4% (£1, 010, 681 average price), whilst the Chilterns sits at 23.5% (£841, 563 average price) and the Cotswolds 41.7% (£628, 529 average price). These areas are ideally positioned for commuters wanting the best of both worlds: country living and city working.
The same Nationwide Building Society paper (2020) also cited Dorset and South Devon AONBs as having exceptionally high levels of second-home ownership. This could be a benefit or a drawback of property in these areas, depending on your stance. Some homebuyers are all too aware of the detrimental effect large swathes of second-homeowners can have on a community, and may not want to contribute to this. On the other hand, those areas that depend on tourism to maintain the local economy may welcome some buy-to-let holiday rentals that can in fact contribute positively to tourism and by extension the local economy. Ultimately, with a shortage of housing stock and the ‘ghost town’ effect second home ownership can have, it is a contentious point to ponder.
Drawbacks to Living in a National Landscape/AONB
The restrictions on planning and development within AONBs can be a hindrance as well as a help. Whilst Permitted Development rights do apply, even these are more restrictive in AONBs. Whilst many homeowners will benefit from their surroundings remaining largely untouched by development and only extended, remodelled or built upon in a highly controlled way, in many cases permission is needed for relatively minor works or alterations. Projects can be thwarted or face a protracted and expensive planning application process. Furthermore, the cost of works themselves can be higher when specific materials, in-keeping with the natural landscape, need to be used. Suffice to say, homebuyers intent on doubling the size of a property may be well advised to steer clear of AONBs.
What is more, whilst the planning policies in these areas are restrictive, they are not prohibitive. Local Authorities and National Landscape teams have to manage the growing demand for housing stock with conservation and preservation, and there have been cases of controversial, large-scale developments within AONBs being approved after a protracted battle with local authorities, campaigners and even the Secretary of State. In this way, the protection conferred by AONB status is not a certainty.
For example, in 2021 a planning inspector approved a 133-unit development for assisted living properties within The Chilterns AONB, on the grounds that the need for homes for the elderly were ‘exceptional circumstances’ outweighing the planning restrictions. There are plentiful other cases where Local Authorities have been taken to court (and in some high-profile cases, the High Court) over their decision to block applications, or overturn previously granted permission. For example, in May 2024, a case against Canterbury City Council’s controversial decision to grant Planning Permission to a Kent Winery in an AONB reached in High Court; the court denied the application for a judicial review of the planning decision, and the development is due to go ahead.
Lastly, although the number of visitors that specific areas attract will vary, the fact that some 170 million visitors are recorded across all 46 AONBs each year shows that the draw is not insignificant. Some homeowners would find an annual influx of visitors and tourists as a frustration or annoyance. Others would be happy to share their slice of picturesque countryside with visitors. The individuals’ stance on this, and the extent to which tourism affects the local economy and community, will no doubt determine whether this is a pro or a con.
Proposals for new AONB
The government is proposing the Yorkshire Wolds and Chester Sandstone Ridge as new AONBs, as well as expanding the boundaries of the Chilterns and Surrey Hills sites. Potential buyers might then be considering buying in these areas, to later benefit from the higher value their property will likely command if the area is designated an AONB. The figures from Nationwide and Knight Frank certainly suggest the premium buyers are willing to pay is considerable, but the planning restrictions may also deter a large cohort of buyers.
Summary
Living within an AONB not only affords homeowners access to the countryside and nature, but also some security in the knowledge that the local area is legally protected from much development that might otherwise mar or spoil the scenery. That being said, property within AONBs command a premium, so homebuyers seeking this protected country idyll will need to pay higher than average prices. Furthermore, homebuyers will need to be aware of the limitations on any extensions or planning proposals they may hope to gain approval for. Although development in AONBs is highly controlled, as the demand for housing stock increases the pressure on Local Authorities and all partners managing AONBs will increase also. However, the government is considering additional AONBs, indicating a clear intention to protect larger areas of exceptional beauty.